Every year on October 18, Canadians mark Persons Day (Journée de l'affaire « personne »), commemorating the pivotal 1929 constitutional judgment that affirmed women's legal status as "persons" qualified to hold public office in Canada. This watershed victory permanently transformed the landscape of Canadian parliamentary democracy and established fundamental jurisprudence on constitutional interpretation.
The Legal Standoff: Section 24 of the British North America Act
In the 1920s, despite Canadian women having achieved federal voting rights in 1918, successive Canadian federal governments maintained that women could not be appointed to the Senate of Canada. The government pointed to Section 24 of the British North America Act (1867), which stated that the Governor General shall summon "qualified Persons" to the Senate—a clause traditionally interpreted under British common law to mean only men.
When prominent Alberta magistrate Emily Murphy was proposed for a Senate seat, critics objected that she was not legally a "person." In 1928, the Supreme Court of Canada unanimously ruled against Murphy, holding that the original intent of the 1867 framers excluded women from the definition of persons.
The Courageous Famous Five of Alberta
Undaunted by the Supreme Court’s denial, five trailblazing Alberta women—collectively immortalized as the "Famous Five"—petitioned to take their appeal directly to the British Empire's highest appellate body, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London:
- Emily Murphy (1868–1933): First female magistrate in the British Empire and principal orchestrator of the constitutional appeal.
- Henrietta Muir Edwards (1849–1931): Legal scholar, suffragist, and founding member of the Victorian Order of Nurses.
- Nellie McClung (1873–1951): Renowned author, orator, and member of the Alberta Legislative Assembly who led the Manitoba suffrage fight.
- Louise McKinney (1868–1931): First woman elected to a legislature in the British Empire (Alberta, 1917) and temperance organizer.
- Irene Parlby (1868–1965): Farm women’s advocate and the first female cabinet minister in Alberta history.
The 1929 Ruling and the "Living Tree" Doctrine
On October 18, 1929, Lord Chancellor Lord Sankey delivered the Privy Council's historic ruling, writing: "The exclusion of women from all public offices is a relic of days more barbarous than ours."
Sankey established Canada's celebrated "Living Tree Doctrine" of constitutional interpretation—stipulating that the Canadian Constitution is "a living tree capable of growth and expansion within its natural limits," meaning legal rights must evolve with modern democratic standards rather than being frozen in 1867.
From Judicial Victory to Historic Appointments
Following the Privy Council's landmark decision on October 18, 1929, Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King moved quickly. In February 1930, Montreal philanthropist and activist Cairine Wilson was appointed as Canada’s first female Senator.
Governor General's Persons Case Awards
In 1979, to mark the 50th anniversary of the decision, the Government of Canada instituted the annual Governor General’s Awards in Commemoration of the Persons Case. Conferred on Persons Day, the prestigious honor recognizes Canadian women and men who have made outstanding contributions to advancing gender equality and social justice across the nation.